Adoptive Mothers and Maternity Leave: Supreme Court Ruling

The Supreme Court struck down the age limit on maternity benefits for adoptive mothers. What the ruling means for adoptive families.

Advocate Sharda Ahuja

10/16/20266 min read

photo of white staircase
photo of white staircase

Hamsaanandini Nanduri v. Union of India & Ors. | 2026 INSC 246

Can a mother be denied maternity benefits simply because the child she adopts is older than three months? The Supreme Court of India has answered this question by reaffirming a fundamental constitutional principle: motherhood is about care, bonding and responsibility not merely biology.

Does the Age of an Adopted Child Determine a Mother's Rights?

Imagine a woman who adopts a child after a long legal process. She welcomes the child into her home, begins building an emotional bond and assumes the responsibilities of parenthood.

Yet, when she seeks maternity benefits to care for her child, she discovers that the law may deny her that benefit simply because the child is older than three months.

Can the law recognise her as a mother but deny her the time and support needed to nurture that relationship?

This was the constitutional question at the heart of Hamsaanandini Nanduri v. Union of India & Ors., decided by the Supreme Court of India on 17 March 2026.

In a landmark judgment, the Supreme Court struck down the three-month age restriction for adoptive mothers seeking maternity benefits. The ruling places equality, reproductive autonomy and the welfare of the child at the centre of maternity protection.

1. Background of the Case

The petitioner, Hamsaanandini Nanduri, an adoptive mother of two children, challenged Section 5(4) of the Maternity Benefit Act, 1961, as amended in 2017.

The provision granted an adoptive mother twelve weeks of maternity benefits from the date the child was handed over, but only where the adopted child was below three months of age.

This created a statutory distinction between women adopting younger children and those adopting children aged three months or older.

The petitioner contended that this restriction violated Articles 14, 19(1)(g) and 21 of the Constitution of India.

During the proceedings, the Code on Social Security, 2020 became relevant because its Section 60(4) contained a corresponding restriction. The Supreme Court therefore examined the validity of the provision under the new Code as well.

2. The Central Legal Issue

The principal question before the Court was:

Can the State constitutionally deny maternity benefits to an adoptive mother solely because the adopted child has crossed the age of three months?

The dispute required the Court to examine the relationship between statutory maternity protection, the constitutional guarantee of equality and the rights of adoptive parents and children.

The Court also considered whether the age restriction was workable in practice, given the time required to complete legal adoption procedures.

3. What Did the Supreme Court Hold?

A Bench comprising Justice J.B. Pardiwala and Justice R. Mahadevan delivered the judgment on 17 March 2026.

The Court struck down the three-month age restriction under Section 60(4) of the Code on Social Security, 2020.

It directed that the provision be read to entitle a woman who legally adopts a child, irrespective of the child's age, or a commissioning mother, to twelve weeks of maternity benefits from the date the child is handed over.

The ruling removed the arbitrary age-based distinction and recognised that the need for parental care and emotional bonding does not disappear when an adopted child crosses a particular age threshold.

A. Article 14: Equality Before the Law

Article 14 guarantees equality before the law and equal protection of the laws.

The Court examined whether the distinction between adoptive mothers based on the age of their adopted children had a rational connection with the purpose of maternity benefits.

The object of such benefits includes enabling a mother to care for the child, develop an emotional bond and facilitate the child's integration into the family.

Those needs do not cease to exist merely because an adopted child is three months old or older.

The age restriction therefore created an unjustified distinction between adoptive mothers who were similarly situated in relation to their caregiving responsibilities.

Legal principle: A statutory classification must have a rational connection with the object of the legislation. An arbitrary age threshold cannot be sustained merely because it appears in a statute.

B. Article 21: Reproductive Autonomy and Dignity

Article 21 protects life and personal liberty.

The Court recognised adoption as a legitimate means of forming a family and an expression of reproductive autonomy.

Family relationships cannot be understood exclusively through biological connections. Adoption creates meaningful relationships grounded in affection, responsibility and emotional bonds.

Denying maternity benefits to an adoptive mother because of the child's age can undermine the opportunity for the parent and child to adjust to their new relationship.

The Court's reasoning thus extended constitutional protection to the realities of adoptive parenthood and the child's need for care and integration into the family.

C. Motherhood Is Not Limited to Biological Childbirth

One of the most important aspects of the judgment is its understanding of motherhood.

Maternity protection cannot be viewed exclusively through the physical process of pregnancy and childbirth. In the context of adoption, the need for caregiving, nurturing and emotional bonding remains equally significant.

The absence of a biological connection does not diminish the legitimacy of the parent-child relationship.

The Court recognised that the process of becoming a family through adoption deserves meaningful legal recognition.

The broader message is clear: motherhood is not defined by biology alone.

D. The Practical Impossibility of the Age Restriction

The Court also considered the practical difficulties created by the statutory restriction.

Legal adoption involves procedures to establish that a child is legally available for adoption and to complete the adoption process. These procedures can take time.

Consequently, an age restriction of three months could make the statutory benefit practically unavailable to many adoptive mothers, even when they comply with the applicable legal process.

A provision intended to provide social security should not be structured in a way that defeats its own purpose.

The Court's analysis therefore addressed not only the constitutional validity of the restriction but also its practical workability.

4. The Supreme Court's Important Observations on Paternity Leave

The judgment went beyond the immediate question of maternity benefits.

The Court highlighted the importance of recognising caregiving responsibilities and drew attention to the need for a legal framework for paternity leave.

Traditionally, maternity-related laws have focused predominantly on mothers, while the role of fathers in early childcare has received comparatively limited statutory recognition.

The Court urged the Union Government to consider legislation recognising paternity leave as a social security benefit.

This observation raises an important question for employment and social security law:

Should the responsibility of caring for a child rest predominantly on mothers, or should the law facilitate a more equitable sharing of parental responsibilities?

Recognising paternity leave could help address the unequal distribution of unpaid care work and encourage a more balanced approach to parenting.

The Court's observations invite policymakers to consider parental care as a shared responsibility rather than a burden falling exclusively on women.

5. Why This Judgment Matters

The significance of Hamsaanandini Nanduri extends beyond the immediate dispute over twelve weeks of maternity benefits.

For adoptive mothers

The judgment removes the discriminatory three-month age restriction and recognises that adoptive mothers require time to care for and bond with their children, irrespective of the children's age.

For adopted children

It acknowledges that a child's need for security, nurturing and integration into a new family cannot be determined by an arbitrary age threshold.

For employers

The decision reinforces the importance of understanding statutory maternity benefits in accordance with constitutional principles and the applicable legal framework.

For constitutional law

The ruling demonstrates how Articles 14 and 21 can be applied to address discriminatory distinctions in social security legislation.

For gender justice

The Court's observations on paternity leave bring attention to the broader question of how the law recognises and distributes caregiving responsibilities within families.

6. Ratio Decidendi

The essential principle emerging from the judgment is that the entitlement of an adoptive mother to maternity benefits cannot constitutionally be restricted solely on the ground that the adopted child is three months old or older.

Such a restriction lacks a rational connection with the purpose of maternity protection, which includes caregiving, emotional bonding and the child's integration into the adoptive family.

The Court's decision reinforces the constitutional guarantees of equality and dignity while recognising adoption as a legitimate means of forming a family.

7. Key Takeaways for Law Students and Legal Practitioners

The judgment is particularly relevant to constitutional law, labour law, employment law and social security litigation.

The following principles merit attention:

  1. Article 14: Legislative classifications must satisfy constitutional standards of permissible classification and cannot rest on arbitrary distinctions.

  2. Article 21: Reproductive autonomy and dignified family life extend to the formation of families through adoption.

  3. Social security legislation: Statutory benefits must be interpreted in light of their purpose and the practical realities faced by beneficiaries.

  4. Child welfare: The need for care, emotional bonding and family integration cannot be determined solely by the child's age.

  5. Gender justice: The recognition of caregiving responsibilities should extend beyond maternity protection to consideration of paternity leave.

For advocates, the decision is a useful illustration of how constitutional scrutiny can address exclusions embedded in social welfare legislation.

The Law Must Recognise Families Beyond Biology

The Supreme Court's decision in Hamsaanandini Nanduri v. Union of India is an important development in the constitutional understanding of motherhood, adoption and social security.

By striking down the three-month age restriction, the Court reaffirmed that the purpose of maternity protection is not confined to the biological process of childbirth. It also concerns the care, nurturing and emotional integration necessary to build a family.

The judgment further brings the question of paternity leave into the conversation, highlighting the need to recognise caregiving as a shared parental responsibility.

Ultimately, the decision reminds us that a child's need for love, care and belonging does not expire at three months and neither should the law's recognition of an adoptive mother's need for support.

Disclaimer: This article is intended for general legal information and educational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice. Readers should consult the applicable legislation and the full judgment for the legal position relevant to their circumstances.